3 Views of the NHTSA Record


3 Views of the NHTSA Record

September, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:

1. Current NHTSA Deputy Administrator David Friedman:“When automakers have failed to recall vehicles quickly, NHTSA has repeatedly issued the maximum fines allowed by law — more than $140 million in five years.”  Seehttp://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2014/09/16/david-friedman-national-highway-traffic-safety-administration-editorials-debates/15745881/

2.  USA Today Editorial Board:GM withheld key information from regulators. It settled cases secretly, ignored actions by its own employees and left dangerous cars on the road for a decade. But when companies act so deplorably, safety watchdogs are needed most. Whether because of corruption, capture by the industry or just plain cluelessness, NHTSA failed.

Congress wants to beef up the agency’s powers and open more data to the public. OK. But an empowered lapdog is still a lapdog. What’s needed is leadership that changes the agency’s ways.”  See

http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2014/09/16/gm-ignition-switch-recall-auto-safety-nhtsa-editorials-debates/15745713/

3. Ralph Nader:

“Today, NHTSA operates more as a consultant to the auto companies as executives pass back and forth between regulatory agency and regulated business as if they were merely divisions of the same firm. NHTSA holds secret meetings with auto companies. The agency has not ordered a manufacturer to recall its defective vehicles for 35 years.

NHTSA needs to end its criminally negligent “business as usual” relationship with auto companies. Only congressional action fueled by the organized outrage of aggrieved families can change the deadly status quo.”  See

http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2014/09/17/ralph-nader-safety-nhtsa-investigation-regulation-congress-gm-stalled-column/15801047/

Current Reality:

There is a clear and present danger we face every day – here in the U.S.A.  Crash deaths in the U.S. currently occur at a rate of nearly 100 per day.  Serious crash injuries occur at the rate of nearly 400 per day.  Crash injuries of all severities occur at a rate of about 6,000 per day.  Societal losses from U.S. crash losses amount to more than $2 Billion per day in the U.S.A. 

As I wrote in the July 2014 Monthly Report:

“The GM Recalls come at a time when the nation is celebrating its Declaration of Independence that held “Safety” as a fundamental purpose. During just the expected 8 years of President Obama’s Administration, the nation is on track to record nearly 250,000 crash deaths (more than twice the number of Americans killed in the Afghanistan, Iraq, Korean, and Viet Nam Wars — combined).   Plus 1 million serious crash injuries.   And all crashes are expected to result in $7 Trillion of societal losses in America during these eight years.”

A higher national safety priority is needed to protect Americans from crash force violence that is killing, maiming, and costing enormous U.S. treasure. See   https://www.careforcrashvictims.com/assets/MonthlyReportforAugust2014.pdf

Lou

 

Senate Hearings Scheduled for September 16, 2014 on NHTSA Role in GM Recall Coverup


Senate Hearings Scheduled for September 16, 2014 on NHTSA Role in GM Recall Coverup

August, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:

See my August 2014 Monthly Report (attached) on this next Hearing.

As we hear about violence in Iraq, think about the crash violence here in America going on now and for more than a century in the U.S.A. – more than 3.6 million Americans have died of crash injuries.
See Crash Death and Serious Injury Clocks at https://www.careforcrashvictims.com/clock.php
As we hear about boots on the ground, think about the NHTSA bureaucrats DUI of the auto industry and going in and out through the NHTSA Revolving Door.
Lou

 

GM Recall Scandal Ignites Nader Call for Legislation and Senate Bill Introduced


GM Recall Scandal Ignites Nader Call for Legislation and Senate Bill Introduced

August, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:

See Nader interview at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZZHeIArIRQ

See informative articles on introduction of Senate Bill athttp://www.detroitnews.com/article/20140801/AUTO01/308010094/1148/rss25#comments

See Bill Summary athttp://www.mccaskill.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/MVHSEASummary.pdf

and http://www.mccaskill.senate.gov/media-center/news-releases/automotive-and-highway-safety-bill-introduced-by-mccaskill

Lou

NHTSA and Hyundai Agree to a Civil Penalty of $17.35 Million


NHTSA and Hyundai Agree to a Civil Penalty of $17.35 Million

August, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:
NHTSA – Hyundai Agreement The attached Agreement was co-authored by NHTSA & Hyundai in private meetings.  As you read it consider the following questions: 
1.  What should the corporate penalty be for withholding from the public information that could result in preventable deaths and disabilities for American people?
2.  Who should decide?
3.  Under what transparency conditions should the decisions be made?
Senate Bill on Penalties
Senate Hearings Ahead
Senator McCaskill’s Committee is holding Hearings soon on NHTSA’s performance and participation in both GM and NHTSA’s failures to protect the public — for nearly a decade in the case of the GM Ignition Switch Recall.
The Times asked for comment:

“Rosemary Shahan, president of Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety, said that provision may be a result of regulators being “under more scrutiny than ever before,” but that it was a welcome surprise.

“I hope it’s a trend,” she said.”

I agreed and thought the agreement penalty was a slap on the wrist for a corporation of Hyundai’s size.How does one judge the significance of a NHTSA – Hyundai agreement penalty of $17.4 million?

Hyundai – NHTSA Agreement on Value of Fine

The cost of a single 30 second ad for the Super Bowl was $4 million plus a production cost of about $1 million.  Seehttp://admeter.usatoday.com/story/sports/ad-meter/super-bowl/2014/01/20/ad-meter-story-super-bowl-ad-costs/4476441/

Hyundai bought two 30 second ads for this last Super Bowl at a cost approaching $10 million.  Seehttp://adage.com/article/special-report-super-bowl/hyundai-advertise-fox-s-broadcast-super-bowl-xlviii/244008/http://adage.com/article/special-report-super-bowl/super-bowl-ad-chart-buying-super-bowl-2014/244024/

Compare that $10 million to NHTSA’s annual budget for the Office of Defects Investigation which also is about $10 million.
Now let’s compare the cost of those two Super Bowl ads to the DOT policy value of just one statistical life — $9.1 million.  See attached DOT Policy Guidance on Value of Life (a morally reprehensible but required bureaucratic policy exercise of placing a dollar value on life).  
Why Did NHTSA Agree?
Appearances often are important in Washington especially when an agency and a company are facing negative scrutiny for known failures to protect people in favor of profits.  As a regulator, if NHTSA has been shown to be a weak regulator, it must at least appear tough before the Hearings.  
And if you can make GM look like it is not as bad as others, too, that’s a smart political opportunity.   As shown in NHTSA – Hyundai Agreement “Nature of Action” items 5, 6, and 8 both GM and Hyundai were notified by their supplier of a brake fluid corrosion problem in 2012.  GM, in November 2012, issued a Technical Service Bulletin (TSB) to its dealers in the U.S. and informed its customers.  Hyundai, in March 2013, issued a TSB to its dealers but not to its customers.
The Agreement states:
“WHEREAS, it is the mutual desire of NHTSA and Hyundai to resolve the TQ14-002 without the need for further action, to avoid the legal expenses and other costs of a protracted dispute and potential litigation:…”  Hyundai and NHTSA agree to the terms of the Consent Order (See attached).
Note: To my knowledge, neither crash victims past, present, and future nor consumer advocates were participants in these private meetings between NHTSA and Hyundai.  Nor does the Agreement address the tax deductibility of the civil penalties or legal and other expenses of Hyundai.  So taxpayers may be paying for this in more ways than one.
Hopefully, the Hearings will address these issues on behalf of the public interest as consumers, taxpayers, insurance premium payers, and motorists, cyclists, and pedestrians.  
The NHTSA – Hyundai Agreement came out as the nation was noting the 40th Anniversary of the resignation of President Nixon for criminal activities, abuses of power, coverups, and obstruction of justice.  One can read transcripts of the Watergate Tapes with discussions of Nixon with CEOs of Ford and GM (Henry Ford II, Lee Iacocca, John Roche) discussing weakening auto safety and air pollution regulations.  See https://www.careforcrashvictims.com/assets/Nixon-Transcriptions.pdf
Presidents Nixon, Reagan, both Bushes, Clinton and Obama, as well as VP Biden, and candidate Romney have failed the American people.  More than two million Americans have died of crash injuries since Nixon took office.  Seehttp://www.fairwarning.org/2012/09/a-strange-indifference-to-highway-carnage/
So is the NHTSA – Hyundai Agreement more evidence of covering up the corporate control of NHTSA?
Lou

 

A Step Toward A Safer America – Texting to 911- Safer America, Care for Crash Victims, Crash Statistics, USA Crash Deaths Statistics, USA Crash Research


A Step Toward A Safer America – Texting to 911

August, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:

Please see new FCC Action on Texting to 911.http://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-adopts-rules-promote-widespread-text-911-availability

Lou

 

U.S. News Article on GM Recall and Nader’s Warnings


U.S. News Article on GM Recall and Nader’s Warnings

August, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:

To recognize Nader’s warnings, it takes a scandal involving tragedies….

See http://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/susan-milligan/2014/04/02/gms-recall-debacle-shows-ralph-naders-auto-warnings-still-ring-true

And we still don’t know how much GM and NHTSA knew using OnStar data.  

“OnStar handles about 10,000 emergency service requests a month, GM says. The figure that could go down as drivers have a greater understanding about what is (and isn’t) going on with their car….

A company spokesperson declined to comment on how the system’s data could have informed GM about faulty parts.”

See  http://fortune.com/2014/08/06/gm-car-safety-mary-chan/

Over the decade of this scandal, a GM report, published by NHTSA, in 2007 suggests there may have been about 3,500 airbag non-deployment frontal crashes.

Has NHTSA requested all such airbag non- deployment frontal crash OnStar data be made available to the public?
Lou

 

NHTSA Web Site Launches Recall Status of Vehicles by VIN Look Up


NHTSA Web Site Launches Recall Status of Vehicles by VIN Look Up

August, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:

Good News:  NHTSA has a new tool to help motorists with recalls.  See

http://www.nhtsa.gov/About+NHTSA/Press+Releases/2014/New-free-online-search-tool-for-recalls-using-VIN-released