Will GM Recall Spur Auto Safety Reform?


Will GM Recall Spur Auto Safety Reform?

July, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:

A must read “reality check” has been published in the LA Times by a giant of auto safety.  

Ben Kelley concludes:NHTSA’s acquiescence in such delays support arguments that it is too responsive to the cost-containment agenda of the auto companies. Its inability to effectively police the industry has almost certainly invited such profit-driven misconduct. Recently, a top agency attorney, in comments to an auto industry group, admitted that “the first line of defense against safety defects is not NHTSA.” Rather, it is the auto companies themselves. “Our agency’s job is to make sure your company is doing its job and to catch problems when it does not,” he said, leaving unaddressed the obvious question of why the NHTSA failed for a decade to “catch” GM’s ignition switch defect.

The answer to that question is that NHTSA is abysmally underfunded and understaffed, and lacks a foundation of tough laws to support its regulatory mission. Nothing in today’s political environment suggests that is going to change soon.”

See http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-0729-kelley-gm-recalls-20140729-story.html

Based on my decades of work at NHTSA and now trying to shine the light on NHTSA’s captivity by corporate interests, I must support his grim conclusion.

When the President of the U.S.A. briefly mentioned auto safety – without noting the problem of more than 150,000 crash deaths on his watch – he used a black Cadillac as a photo prop.  He looked like a corporate puppet moving on the strings of GM.  How’s that for use of the bully pulpit? 

See http://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2014/07/15/president-speaks-importance-our-nations-infrastructure

I voted for him twice.   I hoped he would cut the GM control of auto safety positions and deadly policies at NHTSA.  Tragically for too many Americans that has not happened.  
As usual, we must thank Ben Kelley for giving us this reality check.
And we must again thank the LA Times for this article and Michael Hiltzik for the question that continues to haunt and challenge the nation:  “Only oversight by a Congress and president truly devoted to the public interest, not commercial interests, can keep regulatory agencies focused on the people’s business.

But when business gets its say on Capitol Hill and the White House too, what’s the ordinary person to do?”

See  http://articles.latimes.com/2014/jan/26/business/la-fi-hiltzik-20140126

Lou

 

Obama To Talk Auto Safety — To Defend Tragic Years of Failure to Protect American Crash Victims


Obama To Talk Auto Safety — To Defend Tragic Years of Failure to Protect American Crash Victims

July, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:

Tomorrow President Obama will try to divert public attention from his failures to protect Americans from crash injuries by touting DOT funding of research of auto companies.“Washington — President Barack Obama on Tuesday will tout the importance of “vehicle to vehicle” technology research that could one day help save tens of thousands of road deaths, the White House said.”

“The speech may provide Obama’s most significant direct remarks on auto safety since taking office. Despite Toyota Motor Corp.’s sudden acceleration crisis in 2010 and General Motors Co.’s ongoing ignition switch problem and massive recalls, Obama has said little about road safety during his tenure.

“Instead he has repeatedly focused on his administration’s efforts to improve fuel efficiency and the fact that the administration saved General Motors and Chrysler Group LLC as part of the $85 billion auto bailout.”

From The Detroit News: http://www.detroitnews.com/article/20140714/AUTO01/307140105#ixzz37V34lHZc

Lincoln reportedly said “You can fool all of the people some of the time…”

President Obama will not do that this time.  The record is now too well known by too many people.  More Americans died of crash injuries under Mr. Obama than died in the Iraq, Afghanistan, Viet Nam and Korean wars combined.  Under President Obama more than 180,000 Americans died of crash injuries nearly 1 million suffered serious injuries and societal costs are approaching several Trillion dollars. See p. 18 crash deaths by year http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/Pubs/812032.pdf  

When President Obama points to NHTSA research funds given to auto companies tomorrow he will find a skeptical public that will be difficult to fool.  Some may even compare numbers in his speech with numbers of Americans who died in crashes in GM vehicles.   See http://www.scienceservingsociety.com/GMvehFats.htmNumbers of people* killed traveling in GM vehicles, 2000-2012

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

Totals

Buick / Opel

612

655

672

717

835

903

980

1047

1037

1156

1139

1192

1234

12,179

Cadillac

257

259

265

288

333

348

430

436

431

390

410

425

393

4,665

Chevrolet

4209

4110

4200

4583

4944

5582

5849

6137

6215

6339

6579

6640

6259

71,646

Oldsmobile

287

346

393

427

516

609

754

881

998

990

1119

1209

1250

9,779

Pontiac

797

744

872

890

1013

1174

1240

1300

1495

1428

1596

1586

1549

15,684

GMC

715

685

760

692

825

969

928

948

1003

998

932

945

831

11,231

Saturn

339

333

360

352

457

457

471

556

509

446

394

346

318

5,338

TOTAL

7216

7132

7522

7949

8923

10,042

10,652

11,305

11,688

11,747

12,169

12,343

11,834

130,522

Is it any wonder that President Obama’s poll numbers are at a low?   

Lou

 

Unfixed Recalled Vehicles Still Endangering Americans – Jeeps in this Case


Unfixed Recalled Vehicles Still Endangering Americans – Jeeps in this Case

July, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:
More than a year after the Jeep Recall not one vehicle has been “fixed” with the addition of a trailer hitch approved both by NHTSA and Chrysler.  “Fixed” is probably an overstatement in that the trailer hitch may be shown to be a woefully ineffective “cheap fix” protection in the real world. 
See video and print story at:
http://www.wusa9.com/story/money/consumer/2014/08/02/nhtsa-recall-jeep-gas-tank-fire-crashes-repair-delay-chrysler/13465847/

Story after story of crash deaths, disabilities, disfigurements in Jeep fire crashes (and in many other crashes) are available at:http://www.autosafety.org/campaigns/15 One burn victim survivor (not in a jeep) tells his story athttp://beyondtheflames.com/index.php/about/ 
What Then Must We Do?
These continuing tragedies keep raising important questions.  When corporations 1. ignore the safety of the American people and their legal duties to protect their customers, workers, shareholders, and suppliers, for more than a year, and 2. when NHTSA (facing a Senate Hearing on its ineffective Recall program) writes Chrysler a letter of complaint, and  3. when people continue to die or be seriously injured;  what is an ordinary citizen to do?

The answer to that question is the great untold American story.
Lou

 

Medical Bankruptcies of Crash Deaths and Serious Injuries


Medical Bankruptcies of Crash Deaths and Serious Injuries

July, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:
One important aspect of crash deaths and serious injuries that is not researched and publicized by NHTSA is medical bankruptcies that result from tragic crashes.  
NHTSA data shows that currently on each average day nearly 100 Americans die of their crash injuries and about 400 Americans suffer serious injuries in crashes.
What NHTSA does not tell us is how many individuals and families also suffer medical bankruptcy.

We do have data on the percentage of all bankruptcies that are due to medical bills in America.  That percentage is 60%.

There is now a play that conveys the preventable anguish that results when the tragedies of serious illnesses and injuries degenerate into medical bankruptcy.  The play is Mercy Killers.

See excerpts from the following Single Payer Action announcement.

“Single Payer Action has been a proud sponsor of Michael Milligan’s one act play — Mercy Killers.

“If you haven’t seen it yet, here’s a clip about the play from when we helped bring Mercy Killers to West Virginia. 

And here’s another from Real News Network about a recent Mercy Killers tour of Maryland.

Michael will be taking Mercy Killers around the country.

Here is the events schedule from the Mercy Killers web site.

Hope you get a chance to see this riveting play.

If you would like to schedule a performance in your area, you can do so through the Mercy Killers contact page.

Onward to single payer.

Russell Mokhiber

Single Payer Action”

CONTRIBUTE
Lou

 


Auto Safety Loophole in the Making in Congress

July, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:

Safety advocates are being forced to oppose new proposed legislation that would create another Safety Loophole.  

In the current world of Congress we see the following work to make Americans less safe rather than more safe.  

Please see attached letter from safety advocates to U.S. House of Representatives Committee leaders.

We see this safety loophole in the making while Americans are dying of crash injuries at a rate of nearly 100 per day and seriously injured at a rate of about another 400 per day.  Why?

Einstein taught over a century ago that E = MC (Squared).    Today we need another formula:  Evil = Money x Corruption (Squared).

Lou

 

 

GM Recall Hearings and Article in National Catholic Reporter


GM Recall Hearings and Article in National Catholic Reporter

July, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:

Colman McCarthy addressed the forthcoming Congressional Hearings and raised important questions (and generously mentioned my efforts).  His article is at http://ncronline.org/news/people/safety-advocate-takes-gm-spinners

The next Hearings are scheduled for Thursday July 17.  Seehttp://www.detroitnews.com/article/20140708/AUTO0103/307080079/1148/rss25

In the 1960s, Colman’s articles in the Washington Post were very powerful contributors to the removal of lead from gasoline and reducing air pollution.  The removal of lead from gasoline (and the consequent reduction of lead in the blood of urban children) now is recognized as one of the major public health advances in the last century.

And it is evidence today of how America can solve its problems.  One of Colman’s great books is very timely today Solutions to Violence.

This book is inspirational and conveys the message in its stories that caring reduces violence and increases peace.  

With gratitude and hope for further progress,

Lou

 

Hyundai Regional Recall & Again NHTSA Sides With Auto Companies Not Americans


Hyundai Regional Recall & Again NHTSA Sides With Auto Companies Not Americans

July, 2014

Dear Care for Crash Victims Community Members:
Correction:  I inadvertently omitted the word “not” in the following sentence:  The correct wording is:The Congress should be able to gain bipartisan support for safety because most of the States not in regional recalls are red States.”

NY Times reports:

Hyundai is recalling about 419,000 vehicles in the United States in three separate actions for brake, electrical and suspension problems, according to reports the automaker posted Friday on the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration website.

The largest recall covers about 225,000 Santa Fe crossovers from the 2001-6 model years. A rust problem could cause a front suspension coil to break, possibly puncturing a tire, according to the automaker’s report. The recall will be regional, covering vehicles originally sold or registered in 20 states that use a lot of road salt in the winter: Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, West Virginia, Wisconsin and the District of Columbia. Hyundai said it learned of the problem through warranty claims.

Consumer advocates have complained for years that regional recalls save automakers money, but because people can move frequently, the recalls can easily miss vehicles. Automakers and N.H.T.S.A., which allows such recalls, say the practice makes sense.

See http://www.nytimes.com/2014/08/02/automobiles/hyundai-recalls-419000-vehicles-in-three-actions.html?mabReward=RI%3A6&action=click&contentCollection=Opinion&region=Footer&module=Recommendation&src=recg&pgtype=article

In a another rust problem involving GM brake lines, GM resisted recall and again NHTSA failed to act. In July the NY Times reported:

Last week, Senator Richard Blumenthal, Democrat of Connecticut, and Senator Edward J. Markey, Democrat of Massachusetts, wrote to N.H.T.S.A., saying they wanted information about the way the agency handles investigations, including defect petitions of the type filed in the G.M. brake case. The senators said they wanted to make sure such investigations “are responded to in a timely and complete manner.”

See http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/08/automobiles/gm-resists-recalling-trucks-over-brake-line-problem.html?module=Search&mabReward=relbias%3Ar%2C{%221%22%3A%22RI%3A6%22}

Hopefully Congressional oversight will stimulate NHTSA to do better protecting people than corporate profits.  The Congress should be able to gain bipartisan support for safety because most of the States not in regional recalls are red States.

See https://www.careforcrashvictims.com/assets/Oct2013-Monthly%20Report-HealthInsurance.pdf

And in this election year, citizens, groups, and media can use free crash death mapping tools that show crash deaths over the past decade by State and by Congressional district.  For example, Kentucky lost 8,666 people to crash injuries over the years 2002 – 2011.  In 2011 alone, the number dying of crash injuries in KY averaged 2 people per day. 

Crash death mapping tools are available at 

https://www.careforcrashvictims.com/CrashDeathMappingTools.php

Lou